Hunter × Hunter chapter 17: Two Identical Choices — what is in it
Hunter Exam arc · 20 pages · 24 characters
Key facts in this chapter
Chapter title is displayed as "N°017- TWO IDENTICAL CHOICES". Multiple speakers discuss attitudes toward exam newcomers. A flashback sequence shows a character destroying others' dreams.
Chapter title TWO IDENTICAL CHOICES appears on this page. Applicant #16 declares he will not pursue becoming a Hunter.
Applicant #16 discusses the majority trial and four-versus-one situation. Gon, Killua, Kurapika, and Leorio are present during the discussion. Several applicants are shown falling or having withdrawn.
Prisoners face at least 100 years of forced labor. Rippo serves as jury for the third round. Rippo is a bounty hunter and director of the jail. One hour lost by candidates equals one year won for prisoners.
Bendotto is a thief and criminal sentenced to 199 years. Prisoners plan to win 72 years through victories. Two children are visible among the candidates. Doors numbered 1 and 0 lead to separate chambers.
The group is inside a stone tower during the Hunter Exam. 72 hours is the time limit mentioned for escaping the tower. The bald applicant is described as possibly an ex-soldier. Killua deduces the opponents' goal is to make the applicants lose time.
Gon volunteers to face the next challenge first. The group stands before a large sealed door inside the tower. Killua places a hand on Gon's shoulder while speaking. The door is marked with prominent symbols and emits light.
Sedokan has been sentenced to 149 years as a Bomber. The confrontation occurs inside a torch-lit stone chamber. Sedokan prefers simple games over physical or intellectual contests.
A stark black-and-white portrait fills the lower half of the page. A young person with long, unkempt dark hair stares sideways with a neutral expression. Vertical lettering reading "SEDOUKAN" runs along the right side of the drawing.
long-haired youth
01
The chapter title "N°017- TWO IDENTICAL CHOICES" appears at the top. A wide panel shows a stone pillar rising against a cloudy sky. Speech bubbles read: "JUST SOME KIND OF EXCITEMENT..." and "I'M NOT LOOKING FOR QUALIFICATION IN THIS EXAM." Sound effect "Viiiiiiiuuuu" echoes near the pillar. In the next panel a man in glasses speaks to another: "AS VETERANS, WE MISTRUST NEWBIES, AND WE HAVE WAYS TO APPREHEND DANGERS WHICH ALLOW US..." while the listener replies "TO PROTECT OURSELVES BETTER." Below, three men gesture animatedly as one says "YOUNG PEOPLE WITH THEIR DREAMS THAT GET MESSED UP..." and another continues "IT'S LIKE A SCENE, THAT WHILE WE PROTECT OUR OWN LIVES, WE LOOK AT OTHERS FALLING ON THE VERGE..." A flashback panel shows a cloaked figure kneeling in a tunnel: "I ENDED WITH ACTING ACTIVELY IN THAT, AND BEGAN DESTROYING THE DREAMS OF 'NEWBIES.'" The final panels depict the same man running desperately with wide eyes: "FINALLY, OBSERVING THIS KIND OF STUFF BECAME MORE INTERESTING THAN THE REST." and "FLEETING EXPRESSIONS OF AMBITIONS AND HOPES THAT GO AWAY FOREVER..."
man with glassessmiling manshort-haired mancloaked figurerunning man
02
A large title banner reads TWO IDENTICAL CHOICES across the top of the page. Below it, a close-up shows a heavyset man with spiky hair and a prominent square nose, sweat beading on his forehead as he looks sideways with a resigned expression. A large speech bubble beside him states, "I DON'T HAVE ANY INTENTIONS OF BECOMING A HUNTER ANYMORE." The man wears a light shirt and rests his hand near his chin, his face filling most of the panel against a textured dark background.
applicant #16
03
A wide panel shows several figures tumbling down a staircase with motion lines and the large SFX FIIUUUUU. A speech bubble reads, "I DON'T HAVE THE INTENTION OF GOING ON. IT'S ALREADY QUITE GOOD THAT I ARRIVED HERE." In the next panel applicant #16 smiles with eyes closed, flanked by two speech bubbles: "AT ONE TIME OR ANOTHER, I KNOW I'M GONNA LOSE, BUT I REALLY DON'T CARE." and "FROM THE THIRD ROUND, WE'RE LESS NUMEROUS, AND THE TRIALS ARE GETTING DIFFICULT." Below, a narrow panel shows a distant group on stairs with the SFX HE HE HE. Adjacent panels feature Gon, Killua, and Kurapika looking forward while applicant #16 continues, "BUT NOW, WE'RE IN THE TRIAL CALLED 'OF THE MAJORITY'. IF YOU STAY AT FOUR VS ONE, NOTHING WILL PREVENT YOU FROM MOVING FORWARD... THERE'S NO REASON TO BE DISCOURAGED." On the far right Leorio reacts with shock, shouting "WHAT?!"
applicant #16GonKilluaKurapikaLeorio
04
Hooded prisoners discuss their sentences in a stone-walled cell. One states they had all been condemned to long punishments of at least one hundred years of forced work. Another notes the time they are losing shortens as much as their time in prison. A third adds that discord is perfect for them and there is nothing better. In a dark panel, Leorio cracks his neck with a loud CRACK, a confident smirk on his face. Below, the control room shows dozens of monitors displaying prisoners moving through chambers. Gon stands watching the screens from behind. Text explains that slowing down the candidates shortens the prisoners' punishment proportionally. A box identifies the jury for the third round as Rippo, a bounty hunter and also director of the jail who decided that one hour lost would mean one year won for prisoners.
LeorioGonhooded prisoners
05
Close-up shows hands gripping metal bars with a loud CLANG. Bendotto, a bald prisoner, speaks while chained, noting that is good but everything is not going as planned. He identifies himself as Bendotto, thief and criminal with 199 years punishment. Hooded prisoners reply that only two more victories are needed and there is no problem, claiming they are less clever than planned. A panel shows door number 1 with hooded figures and Bendotto nearby. Another shows door number 0 where Leorio, Gon, Killua, and Kurapika stand. A hooded prisoner declares that while they win 72 years, the others are going to stay here. In the monitor room, Leorio shouts for someone to take the turn away from him. Gon yells it is his turn. On screen, a hooded prisoner is seen. Bendotto grins and points, saying there are two kids among them and it sounds like an easy victory.
BendottoLeorioGonKilluaKurapikahooded prisoners
06
Inside the tower, Leorio stands with a bandage on his face and questions the long punishment ahead. Kurapika, holding food, firmly declares that is enough. Killua notes he heard what the others were saying and knows what they are looking for. Gon listens nearby. A close-up shows Killua's wide eyes as he warns that if they cannot get out of this tower their 72 hours will become 72 years less for them. Leorio suggests the old guy did it quite well, while Killua adds that if the only thing they want is to make them lose time, all they want is to slow them down. In the next panel Gon looks serious as Leorio explains that the bald guy was certainly an ex-soldier or something like that. Leorio continues that next the bald guy would have done as he wished, but he wished to hit Gon so that Gon would not be able to say he quit. Gon stares ahead with a determined expression.
LeorioKurapikaKilluaGon
07
Gon suddenly raises his hand and shouts that he is going first. Killua turns and asks who is next. Leorio comments that Gon looks quite good while the spiky-haired applicant smiles. Gon stands confidently in his jacket and declares yes when asked if he is sure. Killua places a hand on Gon's shoulder and notes that the next one does not seem to be spiteful. Leorio adds that what the bald guy said should have scared Gon but he does not lack courage. In the large lower panel the group stands before a heavy door marked with symbols. Gon and Killua face the door while Kurapika watches from behind. Gon reassures everyone not to worry because the opponent is not a tough one. Killua looks back with a slight smile as the door looms ahead.
GonKilluaLeorioKurapika
08
In a dark chamber lit only by two flickering torches, Gon stands with his back to the viewer while the slender boy Sedokan faces him from the left. Large white SFX "FiUUUUuuu" and "ヒュゥゥゥ" dominate the upper space as the torches emit "SHOO". Sedokan places a hand on his chest and gestures outward, declaring "Hitting, running, jumping, that kind of stuff is not my thing..." A close-up of his eye appears as he adds "I'm not a fighter. As you can see..." Gon, seen from behind, replies "I thought so." Sedokan continues with a slight smile, "I'm not really gifted with thought games. I prefer the opposite." A small surprised Gon head pops up beside him. Sedokan concludes, "So I prepared an extremely simple game." A boxed label reads "SEDOKAN, BOMBER, PUNISHMENT: 149 YEARS."
GonSedokan
09
A massive impact SFX "TADAN" explodes across the page as Sedokan holds up two lit candles, one in each hand, against radiating speed lines. He stares forward with a neutral expression. In the next panels Gon excitedly agrees "That's OK for me!!" and "Yeah!! It's easy!" while clenching a fist. Sedokan explains the rules from off-panel: "Each one lights a candle at the same time. It's not dynamite." Gon reacts with shock "!?" and "Well..." as Sedokan finishes "The one whose candle's light goes off first has lost." Small figures of both boys are shown standing with their candles in separate panels.
GonSedokan
10
A character with short black hair holds up a long candle in one hand and a short candle in the other, presenting the choice. Small inset panels show close-ups of Gon, Killua, and other applicants reacting with surprise. The black-haired character asks, "WHICH ONE WILL YOU CHOOSE?" A profile view continues the explanation: "O IF YOU WANT THE LONG ONE, X FOR THE SHORT ONE." The group debates using majority rule. One applicant says, "CHOOSE USING THE MAJORITY!" Another notes, "NORMALLY..." and "NORMALLY, WE SHOULD CHOOSE THE LONG ONE." Realizing the trick, someone shouts, "BUT COUNTING ON THIS 'NORMALITY', IT WOULDN'T BE SURPRISING IF THE SHORT ONE IS A TRAP." The group concludes, "THE LONG ONE IS TRAPPED FOR SURE!!" and "IT'S A TRAP...!!" At the end of the hallway, Gon, Killua, Leorio, and Kurapika stand together facing the decision.
black-haired candle holderGonKilluaLeorioKurapika
11
Gon sweats nervously and says, "NEITHER OF THE CHOICES ARE REASSURING..." Leorio rubs his head and replies, "YEP, WE CAN'T KNOW..." and "WELL, IN THAT CASE..." A bald applicant laughs "HO HO" while holding up two cards and states that when forced to choose between two very different answers, people naturally mistrust and cannot decide quickly. Another applicant raises a hand and insists, "WE HAVE ALL THE TIME WE NEED!" and "IT'S A MAJORITY DECISION, SO DON'T HESITATE TO CONSULT OTHERS." The black-haired character sits on the floor with arms crossed, saying, "DON'T RUSH WITH YOUR DECISION." Leorio turns and shouts, "WHICH ONE SHOULD WE CHOOSE?!" and "DAMN!" The final panel shows Gon looking down with a worried expression and an empty speech bubble.
GonLeoriobald applicant with cardsblack-haired candle holderKillua
12
Gon stands determined as Killua and the others urge him to choose. "Pick the good one!" someone calls. "We'll follow your decision," another adds. A dramatic panel shows Killua pointing at Gon with intense speed lines: "It's you who's gonna decide! Gon!!" Kurapika explains their trust: "We trust in your instinct. Instead of torturing our minds..." Gon smiles confidently and declares "OK!" then questions "I decide?" The long-haired applicant leans in with a sly grin and asks "The long one? Are you sure?" while others react with surprise "Is he...?" Gon points firmly and announces "I choose the long one!" He grins with certainty, raising a finger: "No doubt!! Yep! Since it's bigger, it will take more time to burn! That's logic!"
GonKillualong-haired applicant
13
Gon stands shocked under a massive radiating impact effect, thinking "He didn't even think about...?" with dramatic SFX "DOOOON" and "と~ん!!" Other applicants watch from the side with varied expressions. A digital display shows "05" with a "BIP BIP" sound as the group discusses the trap. "Anyways, it was impossible to know which one is a trap," one says. "Whatever!" another replies. In a dark room, a figure in a jumpsuit points at the glowing "05 XO" sign and says "OK" while another voice calls "This way." Gon and the long-haired applicant stand before the sign. The long-haired applicant holds up a short candle and says "Short one's for me." Gon holds a long candle and replies "The long one is for you..."
In a dimly lit arena, Gon stands holding a lit candle while a short-haired girl does the same nearby. They both raise their candles toward separate torches. "LET'S LIGHT AT THE SAME TIME..." the girl suggests. Flames ignite with sharp "SHUUU" sounds as both candles catch fire simultaneously. "OUR CANDLES," Gon notes. The two face each other across the space. In a dramatic wide shot with radiating speed lines, Gon thrusts his candle forward and shouts, "MAY THE FIGHT BEGIN NOW!!!" The girl stands ready with her own lit candle.
Gonshort-haired girl
15
The short-haired girl holds her flickering candle as strong wind gusts through the arena, marked by large "FUUUUUU" and "SHUUU" effects. Gon watches with wide eyes, his candle also affected. A wide view shows the arena platform with multiple torches and distant figures. The wind continues blowing fiercely. Elsewhere, Kurapika and Leorio observe a timer reading 08:55:00 and discuss how long the candles might last. Gon reacts with surprise as Leorio warns about the strong wind, advising against bad moves. The girl remains composed amid the gusts.
Gonshort-haired girlKurapikaLeorio
16
Leorio points sharply to the side and shouts, 'LOOK... !' Gon stands holding a lit candle, reacting with a puzzled '...?' as 'SHUU' sounds emanate from the flame. The candle suddenly flares violently with massive 'SHUUUUU' and 'G O O O O' effects, sending up thick smoke and sparks labeled 'PIK' and 'SPAK'. Heavy black smoke billows outward with repeated 'FRUUU' sounds filling the panel. A short-haired woman stands beside a small candle, murmuring 'HE-'. Gon stares at his rapidly melting candle as 'SHUUU' rises from it. Leorio yells in alarm, 'GON'S CANDLE IS BURNING MUCH FASTER! LOOK AT GON'S CANDLE!!'
GonLeorioshort-haired woman
17
The candle continues to flare with 'SHUUU' effects as Leorio declares, 'THERE MUST BE SOMETHING INSIDE THE WAX SO THAT THE CANDLE BURNS MUCH FASTER!!' Gon touches the flame and exclaims 'IT'S HOT!' while noting 'IT BECAME THAT SHORT SO FAST!!' Killua watches from behind. Leorio concludes, 'JUST AS WE THOUGHT, THE LONG ONE WAS A TRAP!!' and adds 'AT THIS RATE, IN 2 OR 3 MINUTES, HE WON'T BE ABLE TO HOLD IT ANYMORE!!' The short-haired woman stands with her back partly turned, saying 'HE HE' and 'NOT COMPLETELY!!!' A close-up shows a long-haired man with a sly expression. Large text declares 'BECAUSE I PREPARED... FOUR OTHERS!!!'
GonLeorioKilluashort-haired womanlong-haired man
18
The black-haired applicant smirks as he reveals his plan. "THIS 'DIFFICULT' CHOICE HELPED ME TO HIDE MY TRICK!" he declares. Narration explains the trap: "YOU NEVER THOUGHT THAT BOTH COULD BE TRAPS. YOU HESITATED ON WHAT TO CHOOSE, BUT..." He continues, "THE ONE I WOULD HAVE GIVEN HIM WOULD BE THE ONE THAT BURNS FASTEST. EVEN IF HE HAD CHOSEN THE SMALL CANDLE..." Gon stands nearby holding a lit candle, flames flickering. Suddenly the applicant’s eyes widen in shock with a "!?" as Gon grins mischievously and chuckles "Hihi". The applicant gasps "OH!!" while Gon points at the candle and reasons, "IF THE CANDLE BURNS THAT WELL... THERE'S NO WAY IT CAN GO OUT WITH THAT BREEZE." Impact lines and "TAP" and "TAC" sound effects punctuate the moment as the candle stays lit despite the breeze.
Gonblack-haired applicant
19
Gon leaps forward and slams the black-haired applicant to the floor with a massive "SLAM !!!" impact. The defeated applicant lies sprawled as Gon stands victorious. In a small panel Gon flashes a peace sign and shouts "I WON!!!" The applicant stares in disbelief with "EHH". A close-up shows the applicant’s wide eye and sweat as he thinks "HOW FAST !!!". Leorio, adjusting his glasses, comments "HE'S AGILE!" and "OH." while Killua watches silently from the side with a neutral expression. The page ends with an arrow labeled "Fin".
Gonblack-haired applicantLeorioKillua
End of chapter20 pages
Discussion
The game involves each boy lighting one candle at the same time. The loser is whoever's candle flame extinguishes first. Sedokan confirms the candles are ordinary and not explosives.
A choice is offered between a long candle and a short candle. Majority rule is proposed as the method to decide. Applicants conclude the long candle is trapped. Gon, Killua, Leorio, and Kurapika are present at the location. The setting is a stone corridor ending at a metal door.
Gon expresses doubt about both candle options. A bald applicant laughs while holding cards. The group is advised to take time and consult others. The black-haired character sits calmly on the floor. Leorio becomes visibly frustrated with the choice.
Gon is given the final say in choosing the path. The group decides to follow Gon's choice without further debate. Gon selects the long path based on burning time logic.
The number 05 is displayed on a digital panel. Gon receives the long candle while another takes the short one. Applicants realize the choice was a trap they could not predict.
Gon wears jacket marked 405 Both characters successfully light their candles at the same moment The arena features wall-mounted torches
A timer shows 08:55:00 during the challenge Strong wind is blowing across the arena floor Gon and the girl are on an elevated platform
Gon's candle burns faster than expected Smoke and sparks are produced by the candle Leorio notices and points out the anomaly first
The long candle was intentionally a trap Something inside the wax accelerates burning The short-haired woman prepared four additional candles
The black-haired applicant set a double-trap using two candles of different burn rates. Gon chose the candle that burns steadily and resists the breeze. The applicant is visibly surprised when Gon’s candle stays lit.
Gon physically overpowers the black-haired applicant in a sudden slam. Leorio and Killua observe the outcome from the sidelines. The sequence concludes the candle confrontation on this page.
What is said, page by page
Man states he seeks only excitement, not qualification. Veteran explains distrust of newcomers and protective methods. Listener affirms the need to protect themselves. Speaker reflects on ruined dreams of the young. Narrator describes watching others fall while protecting themselves. Flashback voice admits actively destroying newbies' dreams. Voice notes how observing this became more interesting. Final line laments fleeting ambitions and hopes.
applicant #16 states he has no intention of becoming a Hunter anymore
unseen speaker says they have no intention of going on applicant #16 admits he expects to lose but does not care applicant #16 notes fewer participants and harder trials from round three applicant #16 explains the majority trial and four-versus-one rule applicant #16 encourages not to be discouraged Leorio reacts with shock saying WHAT?!
Hooded prisoner states they had all been condemned to long punishments of at least 100 years of forced work. Hooded prisoner says the time they are losing shortens as much as their time in prison. Hooded prisoner claims discord is perfect for them and there is nothing better. Narration box explains jury for third round is Rippo, bounty hunter and jail director whose lost hour equals one year won for prisoners.
Bendotto says that is good but everything is not going as planned. Bendotto identifies himself as Bendotto, thief, criminal, 199 years. Hooded prisoner says only two more victories and no problem. Hooded prisoner claims they are less clever than planned. Hooded prisoner states while we win 72 years the others are going to stay here. Leorio shouts take the turn away from me. Gon yells it is my turn. Bendotto says look there are two kids among them and sounds like an easy victory.
Leorio questions the length of the punishment while standing with a bandage. Kurapika firmly tells Leorio that is enough and stands holding food. Killua states he heard what they were saying and knows what they are looking for. Killua warns that their 72 hours will become 72 years less if they cannot escape the tower. Leorio notes the old guy handled it well and that the opponents only want to waste time. Leorio explains the bald guy was likely an ex-soldier who would have tortured Gon to force him to quit.
Gon enthusiastically volunteers to go first by raising his hand. Killua asks who is next after Gon steps forward. Leorio notes that Gon looks quite good for the task. Gon confidently confirms he is sure about going. Killua observes that the next opponent does not seem spiteful. Leorio praises Gon's courage despite the earlier threat. Gon tells the group not to worry because the opponent is not tough.
Sedokan states that physical activities like hitting or running are not his style, speaking calmly with hand on chest Sedokan claims he is not a fighter while smiling faintly Gon responds from behind that he had suspected as much Sedokan admits he lacks talent for thought-based games and prefers the opposite approach Sedokan announces he has prepared an extremely simple game instead
Gon enthusiastically accepts the candle game as easy and fine with him Sedokan clarifies that each participant lights a candle simultaneously and notes it is not dynamite Gon reacts with surprise and hesitation to the rules Sedokan states the losing condition: the first candle whose light goes out loses
black-haired candle holder asks which candle the group will choose voice instructs to use majority rule for the decision applicant notes that normally the long candle would be chosen group realizes the long candle is likely the trap exclamations confirm it is a trap
Gon states neither choice feels reassuring Leorio admits they cannot know the correct answer bald applicant explains why a fast decision is difficult applicant urges the group to take their time with the majority vote black-haired character warns not to rush the decision Leorio demands to know which candle to pick
Killua shouts that Gon must decide, with intense motion lines. Kurapika states they trust Gon's instinct rather than overthinking. Gon confidently accepts the decision-making role. Long-haired applicant questions if Gon is sure about the long path. Gon declares he chooses the long one with certainty. Gon explains his logic that the bigger path will take longer to burn.
Gon reacts with shock that someone did not consider the trap. Applicants discuss that identifying the trap was impossible. The figure confirms the path with OK. Long-haired applicant claims the short candle. Gon accepts the long candle for himself.
Girl proposes lighting candles simultaneously with calm intent Gon acknowledges their candles are now lit Gon dramatically declares the fight's start with excitement
Kurapika estimates candle burn time at five or six hours Leorio notes strong wind on the ground and warns against risky moves Gon reacts with "HO HO!" and "ATTENTION!"
Leorio alerts others to look at something off-panel Gon reacts with confusion to the candle's behavior Short-haired woman makes a quiet surprised sound Leorio warns that Gon's candle is burning unusually fast
Leorio deduces something is inside the wax causing faster burning Gon complains that the candle is hot and shortening quickly Leorio realizes the long candle was a trap Leorio warns Gon cannot hold the candle much longer Short-haired woman laughs and claims it is not completely over Unseen speaker reveals they prepared four other candles
Black-haired applicant boasts about hiding his trick with the difficult choice Narration boxes reveal both candles were traps and the faster-burning one was intended Gon laughs playfully while the applicant reacts in shock Gon explains why the breeze cannot extinguish his well-burning candle
Gon declares victory with "I WON!!!" Applicant reacts with stunned "EHH" Leorio notes Gon’s agility with "HE'S AGILE!" and "OH."