One Piece Chapter 1184: We're All Bones When We Die
One Piece chapter 1184: We're All Bones When We Die — what is in it
Elbaph arc · 13 pages · 13 characters
Key facts in this chapter
Princess Shuri is shown at age 14 in the Kingdom of Esperia. Shuri rejected marriage proposals from five princes due to their weakness.
Brook serves as Battle Convoy Commander in the Kingdom of Esperia at age 27. Adult Shuri flirts with Brook while referencing her increased strength.
Brook and Shuri perform music together on a balcony overlooking the kingdom. Brook's song theme centers on equality in death across social classes.
Young Brook is shown caged outside a music school at age eleven. Brook was denied access to formal music education as a child.
Young Brook created a functional violin from scavenged materials. Brook met a long-haired man who became a mentor figure in the trash dump.
Long-haired man is addressed as Your Highness during meal service. Soup du jour contains abalone harvested from Euro Peninsula and cooked in red wine. Ag Rupee beef is mentioned as part of the meal.
Scene transitions from music performance to fishing on boat then to harbor at Esperia. One day cello port is labeled in panel.
Brook continues singing in warehouse despite being surrounded by armed gang members. Gang members mention curry powder and paid goods during confrontation.
Prince Reuven is addressed directly during a battle involving the Navy and World Government. Reuven shows visible confusion upon hearing the title 'Prince'. Battle convoy from Esperia is mentioned as handling the rest of the fight.
The chapter title page displays the One Piece logo above the words 'Chapter 1184: WE'RE ALL BONES WHEN WE DIE'. Below, a large panel shows Brook's skeleton form being electrocuted by electric jellyfish while swimming in the sea, his afro sparking wildly as he flails amid bubbles and debris. Palm trees and a distant ship appear in the background. At the bottom, text reads: READER REQUEST: "BROOK GETTING ELECTROCUTED BY ELECTRIC JELLYFISH WHILE SWIMMING IN THE SEA" BY PRIMO D. TAKASHI. Credits list By EIICHIRO ODA, Translation: STEPHEN PAUL • Lettering: VANESSA SATONE.
Brook
01
In the Kingdom of Esperia, young Princess Shuri (age 14) stands tall with a massive sword resting on her shoulder. Narration boxes recount: '...UNTIL FIVE PRINCES OF NEARBY KINGDOMS HAD ASKED FOR HER HAND IN MARRIAGE.' and '...TALES OF HER BEAUTY HAD SPREAD... BY THE TIME THE PRINCESS OF ESPERIA WAS 14 YEARS OF AGE...'. Flashback panels show princes collapsing in defeat with cries of 'WHOA!!', 'I YIELD!!', 'WE'RE SO SORRY!!!', and 'YOU'RE SO WEAK!!!'. Shuri declares, '...OR MEN WHO CAN'T PLAY MUSIC!!' and 'I DON'T LIKE WEAK MEN...'. A shocked man yells 'MUSIC ?!!'. A sign identifies 'KINGDOM OF ESPERIA PRINCESS SHURI (AGE 14)'.
Shuri
02
Princess Shuri, now older, smiles and says '...I'M A LOT STRONGER NOW...'. Brook stands beside her in his battle convoy uniform. She continues, 'WELL... I SURE DID! ♡ YOU LIKE STRONG WOMEN, DON'T YOU, BROOK?' and 'I HEAR YOU DEFEATED ALL THE PRINCES IN COMBAT, PRINCESS SHURI?'. Shuri blushes with hearts, replying 'I SUPPOSE YOU ARE. ...AND I'M A LOT CUTER. ♡'. Brook protests 'STOP THAT. IT'S UNDIGNIFIED.' and 'OH, WHY DO YOU HAVE TO TALK LIKE PAPA?!'. Shuri teases 'AND I BET MY CHEST WILL FILL OUT IN THE FUTURE TOO. ♡' while reaching toward him. Brook panics 'WHO'S UNDIGNIFIED NOW?!' and 'AHH, BEAUTEOUS LADIES! ♡ MIGHT I HAVE A GAUDER AT YOUR GARTERS? A PEEK AT YOUR PANTIES?'. A sign reads 'KINGDOM OF ESPERIA BATTLE CONVOY, COMMANDER BROOK (AGE 27)'.
ShuriBrook
03
Brook and Shuri perform together on a balcony overlooking the kingdom. Brook sings 'WE'RE ALL BONES IN THE END! ♪', 'COWS AND FROGS AND SLAVES AND KINGS. ♪', 'WE'RE ALL BONES WHEN WE DIE! ♪', '...SLAVES AND KINGS. ♪', and 'OHHH, COWS AND FROGS AND...'. Shuri joins with 'THAT'S ALL THERE IS TO SAY! ♪' and 'YEAH!!'. In a close-up, Brook strums his guitar with 'YO HO HO! ♪' and 'HA HA HA HA HA HA!'. Shuri laughs 'I LOVE ALL YOUR SONGS, BROOK!!'. She tells him 'IF I HADN'T MET YOUR FATHER... YES, I OWE HIM EVERYTHING.' and '...I'D BE NOTHIN' BUT BONES BY NOW♪♪♪'. Brook replies 'YOU REALLY LOVE PAPA, DON'T YOU, BROOK?' and 'YES, HIS MAJESTY SAID THE SAME THING!'. Shuri adds 'AND MAMA TOO, OF COURSE.'.
BrookShuri
04
Young Brook, age eleven, peers excitedly through the bars of his cage labeled BROOK (AGE 11) at a music school. Inside, children play real instruments while he exclaims, "REAL INSTRUMENTS!! THEY SOUND SO PRETTY." A girl with a violin and other students practice as Brook grins, "HEH HEH! THEY'RE SO LUCKY..." Suddenly adults spot him and shout, "HEY!! YOU'RE SCARING ALL THE STUDENTS!!" "THE SHAME OF THE COUNTRY." "EW, WHAT A STENCH..." Brook flees in panic, "WAAAAH!! I'M SORRY!!" as townsfolk chase him with brooms. In a trash dump he sings to himself, "HOW AM I EVEN ALIIIVE? J EATING TOADS SO I CAN THRIVE! J ...WE'RE ALL STARVING AND SKIN AND BONES! J DAD AND MOM AND LITTLE BRO...J ONE DAY, WE'LL GET TO PLAY REAL MUSIIIIIC! J LET'S BLAME THE KING! J WE NEED A NEW KING! J" while a horned creature growls nearby.
Brook (age 11)young studentstownsfolk
05
The long-haired man questions the boy about his homemade violin, "THAT'S A VIOLIN? IT'S MY VIOLIN. AND...IS THAT...?" The boy replies, "I MADE IT OUT OF A GLASS BOTTLE AND SOME WIRE. DOESN'T IT SOUND NICE?" The man asks, "DID YOU MAKE THEM UP? THESE ARE TERRIBLE LYRICS..." The boy answers, "UH, SURE... WAY TO BE CREATIVE." The man bursts into laughter, "YO HO HO! I GUESS I'LL CALL YOU 'BRO' INSTEAD!" The boy is surprised, "WOW, YOU LOOK SO MUCH OLDER!! YO HO HO HO HO!!" The man admits, "BUT I'M NOT THAT OLD. I'M ONLY 21!! HA HA HA, MAYBE I AM." They continue talking as the boy offers, "ARE YOU A FAN OF MINE, OLD MAN? YOU CAME HERE BEFORE, RIGHT?" Later the boy explains his secret ingredient, "I STEAL IT FROM THE NAVY SHIPS THAT COME TO PORT EVERY NOW AND THEN! IT MAKES EVERYTHING YOU PUT IN TASTE LIKE CURRY!!" and the man cooks, "HERE, BRO, I'LL COOK YOU A MEAL AS A SIGN OF FRIENDSHIP!!"
Brook (age 11)long-haired man
06
The long-haired man eats a fancy meal while a woman in a dress stands beside him. A flashback shows the boy serving soup and explaining, "SHE GRADUATED TOP OF THE CLASS FROM ENOA ACADEMY... YOUR HIGHNESS, THIS IS THE DAUGHTER OF THE CEFRAN ZAIBATSU. ...HARVESTED FROM THE EURO PENINSULA AND COOKED IN RED WINE... THE SOUP DU JOUR IS DOLLAR ABALONE..." The man looks disgusted. Back in the present the boy asks, "WHAT'S UP, BRO? IT'S SO GOOD, IT MADE YOU TEAR UP?" The man replies, "OH... RIGHT... HUH...?" The boy offers to sing, "WHAT?! YOU WANT TO PAY ME? DON'T BOTHER, BRO!! WE'VE EACH GOT OUR TROUBLES, DON'T WE?! HANG ON, BRO, I'LL SING YOU A SONG NOW! I'M GLAD YOU LIKE IT SO MUCH!! YO HO HO HO! SO GOOD, IT MAKES YOU SHIVER, HUH?!" The man suddenly transforms with a massive explosion of power.
long-haired manBrook (age 11)woman in dress
07
The long-haired man plays a wild tune on a flute-like instrument while the boy laughs joyfully with his violin. They fish together from a boat, the boy holding up bottles of liquor. At the harbor the man warns, "LOAD THE MERCHANT SHIP WITH INSTRUMENTS!! BE VERY CAREFUL, THEY'RE FRAGILE! IT'S A NAVAL ESCORT SHIP!!" A sign reads "ONE DAY, CELLO ESPERIA PORT." Later the man confronts the boy, "WHERE'S THE POWDER THE GANGSTERS TOLD YOU TO CARRY?! WHERE'D YOU HIDE IT?! DON'T LIE TO ME, YOU LITTLE MULE." The boy looks terrified, "I DUNNO WHAT YOU MEAN... YOU GOT THE WRONG GUY. KOFF, KOFF!!" as a massive "DOOM!!" impact strikes.
long-haired manBrook (age 11)
08
In a dim warehouse, armed men surround a singing skeleton. Brook continues his melody despite the threats. "EITHER WAY, HE'S SEEN OUR FACES." "IT'LL BE OVER IN A MOMENT IF I KEEP SINGING..." "STOP SINGING !!!" one man yells. "WE'RE ALL BONES WHEN WE DIE! ♪" "COWS AND FROGS AND SLAVES AND KINGS! ♪" Brook sings on. The gang leader shouts, "WE PAID A LOT OF MONEY FOR THAT STUFF, AND YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO GIVE IT TO US!! AND INSTEAD, WHAT DO WE FIND?! CURRY POWDER!!" Another warns, "WE GOTTA KILL HIM AFTER THE GANG!!" Brook replies calmly, "SO LONG, STRAY DOGS... SO LONG, BRO..." Suddenly a massive impact shakes the building. "BROOOOOK!!!" A horned figure stands amid the chaos as men react in shock. "HUH ?!!" one cries. Brook's voice echoes again, "WE'RE ALL BONES WHEN WE DIE! ♪" Prince Reuven appears furious, "PRINCE REUVEN?!!" A subordinate stammers, "B-BRO?!" The impact lands with "DOOM!!" as Reuven pants heavily, "HUFF, HUFF!!"
BrookPrince Reuven
09
Prince Reuven glares as a voice urges, "YOUR HIGHNESS, YOU HAVE TO SET YOUR PERSONAL GRUDGE ASIDE!! THE WORLD GOVERNMENT IS BEHIND THE NAVY!!" Reuven mutters, "PRINCE ...?" and "HUH ...?" A woman with long hair embraces him tightly. "HUGG!!" she cries. "I DON'T KNOW WHAT I'D DO WITH MYSELF IF YOU'D DIED!! I'M SO GLAD YOU'RE ALL RIGHT, BROOK!!" Reuven looks confused. Outside, the battle rages. "LOOK WHAT THESE GUYS DID TO MY LITTLE FRIEND!!" Reuven roars. "DON'T TRY TO STOP ME!! I'LL DO THIS MYSELF!!!" He charges forward. "THE BATTLE CONVOY WILL HANDLE THE REST! STEP BACK, YOUR HIGHNESS!!" A subordinate warns, "HEY, WAIT! THAT'S ESPERIA'S BATTLE CONVOY!!!" Reuven declares, "YOU'RE TRASH!!" Later, he reflects, "THEN... HE REALLY IS JUST A KID WHO LOVES CURRY POWDER?!" A subordinate reports, "...AND THE MULE WHO WAS TRANSPORTING THEIR DRUGS... PRINCE REUVEN, WE'VE CAUGHT THE MOULON FAMILY..."
Prince ReuvenBrookCandelle
10
The confrontation intensifies. A subordinate pleads, "HEY! STOP! WE'RE NAVY!!" Another insists, "I'LL FIGHT AT YOUR SIDE!!" Candelle smiles, "I AM YOUR TRUSTED BLADE, HIGHNESS..." Reuven growls, "NO, YOU'RE NOT!!" and "...THEN THE WORLD'S TRULY COMING TO END! RIGHT, CANDELLE? IF THE GOVERNMENT IS BACKING THIS SCUM..." Candelle stands ready with her weapon. Reuven unleashes a furious attack, shattering the surroundings with "DADA DADA DOOM!!" as debris flies. Candelle fights alongside him. In the aftermath, townsfolk cheer, "SHE'S SAVED THE KINGDOM FROM PERIL! ♡" "LADY CANDELLE'S DONE IT AGAIN!!" A subordinate asks, "HEY, DID YOU HEAR?!" while the horned creature looks stunned.
Prince ReuvenCandelle
11
At Esperia Palace, Brook wakes up. "BLINK.." A subordinate checks on him. "ARE YOU AWAKE NOW, BROOK?!" Candelle stands before Prince Reuven. "I AM NOT ANGRY AT YOU, PRINCE REUVEN." Brook mumbles, "YOU'RE A PRINCE, BRO...?" "YEAH, YEAH. HEY, BROOK!" Reuven replies. Candelle continues, "...THAT YOU BE MORE MINDFUL OF YOUR ROYAL POSITION... I'M SIMPLY ASKING..." Reuven admits, "UH, LISTEN ... ...I JUST HAD TOO MUCH FUN HANGING AROUND YOU TO RUIN THE GOOD TIMES. I'M SORRY I DIDN'T TELL YOU. I WASN'T GOING TO HIDE IT..." Candelle warns, "...WE WENT INTO A PANIC EVERY TIME PRINCE REUVEN WENT MISSING... ALSO, DON'T YOU DARE TELL ANYONE ABOUT STEALING THAT CURRY POWDER!!" A sign reads "KINGDOM OF ESPERIA BATTLE CONVOY, COMMANDER CANDELLE" as the scene settles.
BrookPrince ReuvenCandelle
12
A smiling blonde woman gently taps the head of a small curly-haired musician, saying, "I NEVER WOULD HAVE GUESSED HE WAS PASSING THE TIME WITH SUCH AN ADORABLE LITTLE FRIEND." The little musician reacts with shock, hearts floating up and a "BLOOSH!" sound effect bursting around him. A fierce horned warrior grins widely and shouts, "GIVE HIM A ROOM IN THE BARRACKS AND SOME REAL INSTRUMENTS TO PLAY... ...AND MAKE IT SO HE CAN ATTEND SCHOOL!! THIS GUY'S MY FAVORITE MUSICIAN!!" Other voices chime in around him: "MORE IMPORTANTLY, LISTEN UP!" "IGNORE HIM." "NAH, HE'S FINE..." "OH! I'M SORRY!! I DIDN'T KNOW YOUR WOUNDS WERE SO DEEP!!" Behind them rises a grand domed palace in Esperia. The curly-haired musician is later shown being carried away, dripping with sweat, as the horned warrior continues, "I LOVE THIS GUY!! IF WE KEEP HIM AROUND... ...LIFE IN THE PALACE IS GONNA BE WAY MORE FUN!!!" A silhouetted figure raises both arms dramatically, declaring, "WE'VE GOT A NEW STAR IN ESPERIA!!" The musician stares in confusion, muttering, "HUH...?" The page ends with "To be continued!"
Candelle claims position as trusted blade to Prince Reuven during confrontation. Reuven physically rejects Candelle's offer to fight alongside him. Crowd at Esperia reacts positively to Candelle's actions.
Scene takes place at Esperia Palace after Brook wakes up. Candelle is identified as commander of the Kingdom of Esperia battle convoy. Reuven admits to Brook that he concealed his identity as prince.
The small musician reacts with visible shock to the blonde woman's comment. A large domed building appears in the background of the scene. The horned man claims the musician as his favorite and offers him lodging and schooling. The scene ends with the musician lying down in surprise. The page concludes with To be continued text.
What is said, page by page
Narration states that by age 14 five princes from nearby kingdoms had proposed to Shuri. Young Shuri declares she yields only to strong men who can play music and rejects weak men. Princes apologize and admit they are weak while Shuri stands over them.
Shuri states she is a lot stronger now and asks if Brook likes strong women. Brook responds that he supposes she is stronger and notes she is cuter too. Shuri teases Brook about her future chest size and Brook reacts with embarrassment. Brook questions who is undignified now while Shuri continues playful advances.
Brook sings lyrics about all beings becoming bones in death including cows frogs slaves and kings with cheerful celebratory mood. Shuri compliments Brook's songs and expresses affection during their joint performance. Brook laughs loudly and responds to Shuri while continuing to play guitar on the balcony. Shuri mentions owing everything to Brook's father and notes that both parents loved Brook.
Young Brook expresses excitement at seeing and hearing real instruments inside the music school. Adults scold and chase young Brook away from the school calling him a shame and stench. Young Brook sings about starvation survival and blaming the king while living in the trash dump.
Young Brook explains that his violin is homemade from a glass bottle and wire and asks if it sounds nice. Long-haired man asks if Brook made up the song lyrics and inquires about his age. Brook claims to be twenty-one and discusses his hard life and love of music. Brook reveals he steals curry powder from navy ships and cooks grasshoppers and frogs.
Boy in flashback explains meal ingredients and origin to long-haired man with formal tone and context of high-class service. Long-haired man reacts with visible anger and shock to the soup description, mood of displeasure and intensity.
Long-haired man orders loading of merchant ship with instruments at harbor, intent cautionary and urgent. Long-haired man identifies docked ship as naval escort vessel. Boy expresses joy at music and liquor during boat scene with playful mood.
Armed men threaten to kill Brook after he has seen their faces, mood aggressive and decisive. Brook states he will finish song quickly despite danger, intent defiant and calm. Armed men shout stop singing with urgent anger. Prince Reuven reacts with shock upon recognizing Brook.
Subordinate urges Prince Reuven to set aside personal grudge because World Government backs the Navy; intent: de-escalate. Reuven reacts with confusion muttering 'PRINCE ...?' and 'HUH ...?'; mood: disoriented. Reuven declares 'YOU'RE TRASH!!' toward opponents; mood: aggressive rejection. Subordinate notes Reuven is a kid who loves curry powder; intent: surprised realization. Background figure mentions mule transporting drugs and catching the Moulon family; context: revealing hidden actions.
Subordinate shouts 'HEY! STOP! WE'RE NAVY!!' and offers to fight at Reuven's side; intent: plead for alliance. Candelle states 'I AM YOUR TRUSTED BLADE, HIGHNESS...' with smile; intent: loyal offer. Reuven growls 'NO, YOU'RE NOT!!' rejecting Candelle; mood: furious denial. Candelle questions if the world is truly ending because the government backs the Navy; intent: realization. Crowd cheers that Lady Candelle saved the kingdom again; mood: admiration and relief.
Subordinate asks Brook 'ARE YOU AWAKE NOW, BROOK?!'; intent: check on condition. Candelle tells Prince Reuven 'I AM NOT ANGRY AT YOU'; mood: calm reassurance. Brook mumbles 'YOU'RE A PRINCE, BRO...?'; mood: surprised realization. Reuven apologizes for hiding his royal position and having too much fun; intent: explanation. Reuven warns not to tell anyone about stealing curry powder; intent: secrecy demand.
Smiling blonde woman expresses surprise that the musician spends time with an adorable little friend. Horned man offers the musician a room in the barracks with real instruments and insists he attend school. Horned man declares the musician is his favorite and demands others listen. Character apologizes for not realizing the musician's wounds were deep. Character expresses excitement that keeping the musician will make palace life more fun. Character announces the group has gained a new star in Esperia.