A theory answers a mystery
File every theory under the mystery it answers. If the question is not on the site yet, ask it first, then answer it.
A clue is a page, not a paragraph
A clue names the chapter and page and quotes one or two lines at most. A cropped panel is allowed only next to the argument it supports. Summaries wait for the official release, and links go to the exact chapter on an official service.
Rank sources honestly
The manga outranks SBS answers, Vivre Cards, interviews and the anime. A fan inference is marked as one and is never presented as canon.
Weigh the argument, not the author
Arrows on an argument say whether its clue actually changes the case. A theory you like can rest on a weak clue; one you dislike can cite a strong page.
How confidence works
A theory's confidence comes from its for and against arguments and the arrows readers give them, weighted by reader trust. It stays hidden until enough readers have weighed in, and it shows a ± range until the case is firm.
Moderate with cited reasons
New clues wait for a moderator. Status changes, source corrections and flags carry a specific reason, so readers can see why a call was made.