Create theory

One Piece chapter 856: Liar — what is in it

Whole Cake Island arc · 19 pages · 30 characters

Key facts in this chapter

  • p0Chapter 856 cover titled 'Liar' shows themed group in orchard.
  • p2Group searches Mirror World for Luffy and Sanji.
  • p2Discussion occurs inside mirrored hall with checkered floor.
  • p3Characters discuss preventing or allowing the upcoming wedding.
  • p3Luffy and Sanji recently fought inside the castle area.
  • p4Heavy rain falls over Sweet City at night.
  • p4Jester-hatted child falls and hits ground with loud impact.
  • p5scene takes place on 6th floor of Baum guest room
  • p5large bearded man wears fur-collared coat
  • p5party involves heavy drinking with barrels
  • p6Vinsmoke brothers discuss alliance with Big Mom
  • p6three Vinsmoke brothers appear together smiling
  • p6party continues with toasts in guest room
  • p7guards stationed outside Vinsmoke guest room
  • p7Reiju is located in a separate infirmary
  • p7sleeping child is inside the guarded room
  • p8scene occurs in rainy outskirts of town
  • p8Luffy is severely beaten and lying in mud
  • p8Sanji stands over Luffy without speaking
  • p9Luffy refuses Sanji's command to leave.
  • p9Sanji instructs Luffy to eat the dropped meal.
  • p9The surrounding town is burning and ruined.
  • p9Rain is falling during the confrontation.
  • p10Luffy finds the meal extremely delicious despite its condition.
  • p10Sanji watches Luffy eat with a conflicted expression.
  • p10Rain continues during the meal.
  • p11Sanji accuses Luffy of lying.
  • p11Sanji orders Luffy to leave after eating.
  • p11Luffy reacts with shock to the order.
  • p12Sanji believes he has lost the right to return to the ship.
  • p12Luffy demands Sanji come with him.
  • p12Sanji references his saviors from the Baratie era.
  • p13Sanji raises three fingers while listing reasons.
  • p13Sanji claims his family was framed by Big Mom.
  • p13Luffy states he has no obligation toward the Vinsmoke family.
  • p14Sanji kicks Luffy away after telling him to leave.
  • p14The kick creates a large explosion of debris.
  • p15Luffy grabs Sanji by the collar demanding the truth.
  • p15Sanji is left coughing on the ground after the kick.
  • p16Both Luffy and Sanji are crying heavily with sweat and tears.
  • p16Background crew demands that Sanji cook food.
  • p16Sanji says he wants to go home to the Sunny.
  • p17Luffy and Sanji converse on a ruined landscape during chapter 856.
  • p17Sanji displays tears and sweat while speaking about his family conflict.
  • p17Luffy expression changes from wide-eyed sweat to a broad determined smile.
  • p17Luffy offers to wreck the wedding together with Sanji.

What is said, page by page

  • p2Unseen speaker asks about Luffy and Sanji's whereabouts with urgency.
  • p2Voice emphasizes lack of information despite mirrors.
  • p2Blonde woman suggests location idea outside the castle.
  • p2Group notes weird person sleeping in Sanji's room.
  • p2Characters confirm they have not seen Luffy or Sanji recently.
  • p2Blonde woman states no mirror leads directly to fight location.
  • p3Speaker notes Sanji's possible important Vinsmoke role at wedding.
  • p3Doubt expressed about easily convincing Sanji to return.
  • p3Luffy reacts loudly to mention of fight with Sanji.
  • p3Topknotted character warns wedding ceremony will have serious consequences.
  • p3Plan mentioned to gather everyone back before ceremony.
  • p3Tiger-masked figure states someone nearly died earlier.
  • p4Voice mentions hearing a barking dog in the rain.
  • p4Another voice questions if a gunshot was heard.
  • p4Jester-hatted child mutters about bastards while panting.
  • p4Large top-hatted man curses under heavy rain.
  • p4Dog continues barking near fallen figure.
  • p5large bearded man in fur coat boasts about liking Nami's lion personality in drunken tone
  • p5drunken partygoer mentions preference for the girl Sanji knows and possible capture tomorrow
  • p5another partygoer calls the group pathetic for falling over weak alcohol
  • p5central figure suggests giving drinking a rest until tomorrow night
  • p6large bearded man declares tomorrow is big day and Big Mom alliance will let Germa conquer North Blue
  • p6long-haired Vinsmoke brother thanks Sanji for contribution to future power
  • p6goggled Vinsmoke brother notes army will display Big Mom's Jolly Roger
  • p6third Vinsmoke brother states they used Sanji as bait to capture enormous fish
  • p6background partygoers cheer to the failure
  • p7armored guard orders no contact with Vinsmokes until after tomorrow ceremony
  • p7top-hatted man tells someone to quit blabbering
  • p7bearded man states they have no option but to wait for fate
  • p7figure mentions soldiers positioned around Reiju's infirmary
  • p7blonde woman with gun remains silent while aiming
  • p8Luffy weakly mutters THANDI while lying in mud
  • p8Sanji stands silently in rain above Luffy
  • p9Luffy laughs 'SHISHISHI...' while flatly refusing Sanji's order to leave, showing stubborn refusal mood.
  • p9Sanji snaps at Luffy to get out of sight and hurry, expressing anger and urgency.
  • p9Sanji coldly tells Luffy to eat the meal if he can, with dismissive intent.
  • p9Luffy mutters 'FUD.' while holding rope, indicating hunger despite refusal.
  • p9Sanji notes the meal got rained on and dropped, expressing self-deprecation and failure feeling.
  • p10Luffy shouts 'DELICIOUS!' with pure joy while eating messily, conveying extreme satisfaction.
  • p10Narration emphasizes the meal as 'INCREDIBLY DELICIOUS! THIS IS GREAT!' highlighting quality.
  • p10Luffy continues chewing noisily with eyes closed in bliss.
  • p10Sanji remains silent while observing Luffy with sweat and complicated expression.
  • p11Luffy exclaims 'YUM!' and mentions putting favorite foods in the meal, showing continued enjoyment.
  • p11Sanji coldly calls Luffy a liar and orders him to leave now that eating is done, with firm rejection intent.
  • p11Sanji adds he was about to prune up and calls the meal a failure, expressing frustration.
  • p11Luffy reacts with shocked '!!' to Sanji's sudden order to leave.
  • p12Sanji speaks without turning, admitting he disrespected and injured his own captain despite being saved, with guilt and resolve.
  • p12Luffy roars 'WHAT ARE YOU SAYING?! COME WITH ME!' in furious protest.
  • p12Sanji states he no longer has the right to return to the ship, explaining his decision.
  • p12Sanji refers to his greatest saviors as the shitty gramps and his crew from his past, with solemn tone.
  • p13Sanji explains his family is framed by Big Mom and held hostage with desperate serious mood.
  • p13Sanji states they will be killed in hours while listing reasons with urgent intent.
  • p13Luffy replies he cannot let them die but has no obligation and calls them rotten with conflicted tone.
  • p14Sanji tells Luffy to go back and declares these are the three reasons with cold final tone.
  • p14Sanji orders Luffy to leave now if he understands with harsh glare.
  • p14Impact SFX emphasizes the sudden powerful kick toward Luffy.
  • p15Luffy demands the damn truth while grabbing Sanji with furious intense mood.
  • p15Sanji wheezes and coughs from exhaustion on the ground.
  • p16Background crew yells for Sanji to cook food with urgent desperate mood.
  • p16Sanji starts to speak Luffy's name with emotional breaking voice.
  • p16Sanji declares he wants to go home to Sunny while sobbing heavily.
  • p17Sanji voices conflicted feelings about wanting to save his family scumbags despite not seeing them as family, in pained and desperate mood amid ruined landscape.
  • p17Sanji states he lacks strength to run away before the ceremony starts, expressing helplessness.
  • p17Luffy responds with quiet agreement ...Yeah in initial surprised state.
  • p17Luffy declares with wide grin that the situation is just like Sanji and proposes wrecking the wedding together.
  • p17Luffy shouts they are here for Sanji with energetic and supportive intent.